Rentalio helps you with all your vacation rental needs. Whatever it is that your heart desires whether it be beach house rentals, home rentals or mountain cottages Rentalio helps you find it. Here you can search for rentals from all over the United States and the world. Our fast and intuitive search system need only a few steps to find the exact home rental you seek in the United States, Europe, the Caribbean, Canada, Mexico, Asia and every other corner of the planet.

Showing 83 Vacation Rentals from Shelter Island, NY

Advertise Your Vacation Rental

Shelter Island, NY Vacation Rentals:

 
Nightly rate
394 USD
Property type
Vacation Home
Bedrooms
1
Sleeps
2
Bathrooms
1.5
Amenities:
Laundry, Pets OK
Activities:
-
Vacation Home Description:
description:MANHATTAN BROOKLYN QUEENS BRONX STATEN ISLAND LONG ISLAND WESTCHESTER NEW JERSEY Real Estate Rental - 1 BR, 1 1/2 Bathroom Cottage View Listing Detail Contact Info/ Contact User Return To Listings Rent $12,000 Bedrooms 1 Bathrooms 1.5 Any Fees Pets Allowed County LONG ISLAND Address Town Shelter Island Zip 11964 SHELTER ISLAND POND FRONT COTTAGE FOR TWO This charming one bedroom cottage with lovely gardens edged by a pond is perfect for a couple.;
 
Nightly rate
919 USD
Property type
Vacation Home
Bedrooms
3
Sleeps
6
Bathrooms
2
Amenities:
Pets OK, Swimming Pool
Activities:
Beach
Vacation Home Description:
description:SHELTER ISLAND - VERDANT GROUNDS WITH POOL Verdant grounds, pool, plus close to Crescent Beach, boasts 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, eat-in kitchen, dining room, and living room. But its best assests are outdoors. Swim in a very pirvate pool behind verdant shrubbery, dine beneath a dense pergola, relax on the rocking chair porch. MD-LD $28,000 ;
 
Nightly rate
314 USD
Property type
rental
Bedrooms
3
Sleeps
6
Bathrooms
2.5
Amenities:
Fireplace, Pets OK
Activities:
Kayaking
Vacation rental Description:
description:SHELTER ISLAND-Live on a quiet cul-de-sac surrounded by exquisite gardens, serene and colorful. Country kitchen, big fireplace, and fish from your private pond euqipped with a kayak and rowboat. Perfect for short term rental. Availability includes June 1-21, July 1-14 and August 1-14 and 18-25. (VLS5395737) ;
 
Nightly rate
985 USD
Property type
Vacation Home
Bedrooms
3
Sleeps
6
Bathrooms
2
Amenities:
BBQ, Pets OK, Swimming Pool
Activities:
Beach
Vacation Home Description:
description:SHELTER ISLAND IN THE HEART OF SILVERBEACH WITH POOL ;
 
Nightly rate
985 USD
Property type
Vacation Home
Bedrooms
3
Sleeps
6
Bathrooms
2
Amenities:
BBQ, Pets OK, Swimming Pool
Activities:
Beach
Vacation Home Description:
description:SHELTER ISLAND IN THE HEART OF SILVERBEACH WITH POOL This 3 BR ranch is great for kids. The pool and grassy backyard have ample room to include lawn furniture, a picnic table and barbeque. And don’t worry about kids tracking water through the house ;
 
Nightly rate
328 USD
Property type
Vacation Home
Bedrooms
4
Sleeps
8
Bathrooms
2.5
Amenities:
Air Conditioning, Pets OK, Swimming Pool
Activities:
Beach
Vacation Home Description:
description:SHELTER ISLAND LIGHT, PRIVACY, AND POOL ON QUIET STREET Lush landscaping totally hides this contemporary house from the street. Sunlight streaming through picture windows keeps the common rooms and bedrooms cheery while central air keeps things cool. Trees and a town preserve give the back yard and pool total privacy. The quiet street is just minutes away from Fresh Pond and Wades Beach. Available September $12,000 ;
 
Nightly rate
1149 USD
Property type
rental
Bedrooms
3
Sleeps
6
Bathrooms
2.5
Amenities:
Pets OK, Swimming Pool
Activities:
-
Vacation rental Description:
-
 
Nightly rate
1478 USD
Property type
Vacation Home
Bedrooms
3
Sleeps
6
Bathrooms
3
Amenities:
Air Conditioning, Outdoor Shower, Pets OK, Swimming Pool, Towels, Wireless Internet Access
Activities:
-
Vacation Home Description:
-
 
Nightly rate
1379 USD
Property type
Vacation Home
Bedrooms
4
Sleeps
8
Bathrooms
4
Amenities:
Fireplace, Pets OK
Activities:
Beach
Vacation Home Description:
-
 
Nightly rate
Property type
Vacation Home
Bedrooms
5
Sleeps
10
Bathrooms
3
Amenities:
Fireplace, Patio, Pets OK
Activities:
Beach, Swimming
Vacation Home Description:
description:SHELTER ISLAND-West Neck Harbor is at your fingertips as well as Shell Beach for sunbathing and swimming from this charming 1930's Cape styled home. Completely renovated with an all season porch, Living Room with fireplace, new kitchen and dining area with French doors that lead to a new stone patio and large and private back yard. Five bedrooms with three full baths including Master Bedroom with beautiful harbor views and finished basement. Co-Exclusive $1,295,000 ;
 
Nightly rate
714 USD
Property type
Vacation Home
Bedrooms
5
Sleeps
10
Bathrooms
3
Amenities:
Pets OK, Pool Table, TV
Activities:
Beach, Ping Pong
Vacation Home Description:
-
 
Nightly rate
1511 USD
Property type
Vacation Home
Bedrooms
3
Sleeps
6
Bathrooms
2.5
Amenities:
Air Conditioning, Outdoor Shower, Pets OK, Swimming Pool
Activities:
Beach, Tennis
Vacation Home Description:
-
 
Nightly rate
1478 USD
Property type
Vacation Home
Bedrooms
4
Sleeps
8
Bathrooms
3
Amenities:
Pets OK, Swimming Pool
Activities:
-
Vacation Home Description:
-
 
Nightly rate
Property type
Vacation Home
Bedrooms
3
Sleeps
6
Bathrooms
2
Amenities:
Air Conditioning, Fireplace, Garage, Pets OK, Swimming Pool, Woodburning Stove
Activities:
-
Vacation Home Description:
description:SHELTER ISLAND A GOLFER’S PARADISE-The first thing you see in the morning, the last at night is the 13th green of Gardiner’s Bay Country Club on sensational Shelter Island. Great room with fireplace, 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, newly renovated kitchen with double wall ovens, 2 drawer dishwashers and island. There is a large family room with a woodburning stove, a full basement, central air conditioning and central vacuum, and separate 2 car garage with lots of storage. The views from the house of gently rolling l... ;
 
Nightly rate
262 USD
Property type
Vacation Home
Bedrooms
3
Sleeps
6
Bathrooms
2
Amenities:
Fireplace, Pets OK, Swimming Pool
Activities:
Beach
Vacation Home Description:
-
1 2 3 4 5 6

Cities:

Southold, NY (110)
Greenport, NY (93)
Shelter Island, NY (83)
East Marion, NY (73)
Cutchogue, NY (36)
Orient, NY (15)
Peconic, NY (12)
Shelter Island Heights, NY (9)
Orient Point, NY (4)

How to get there: You may check resources for cheap airline tickets, or if you need Shelter Island, NY car service or Shelter Island, NY airport transportation and limousine rental do not forget to register and receive special 10% discount code.